After each game (until the Covid-19 pandemic struck) the travelling fans aboard Supporters’ Club coaches would vote for an Albion Man of the Match. These were accumulated to produce an Away Player of the Season.
The Away Players of the Season were:
- 2018/19 Shane Duffy
- 2017/18 Mat Ryan
- 2016/17 Lewis Dunk
- 2015/16 David Stockdale
- 2014/15 Lewis Dunk
- 2013/14 Tomasz Kuszczak
- 2012/13 Liam Bridcutt
- 2011/12 Liam Bridcutt
- 2010/11 Glenn Murray
- 2009/10 Glenn Murray
- 2008/09 Andrew Whing
- 2007/08 Michel Kuipers
- 2006/07 Alex Revell
- 2005/06 Paul McShane
- 2004/05 Guy Butters
- 2003/04 Guy Butters
- 2002/03 Danny Cullip
- 2001/02 Michel Kuipers
- 2000/01 Michel Kuipers
- 1999/2000 Danny Cullip
- 1998/99 Gary Hart
- 1997/98 Mark Ormerod
- 1996/97 Paul McDonald*
- 1995/96 Nicky Rust*
- 1994/95 Nicky Rust*
- 1993/94 Nicky Rust*
- 1992/93 Steve Foster*
- 1991/92 Gary Chivers*
- 1990/91 Perry Digweed*
* The award began in 1990/91 when official Albion coaches were stewarded by Supporters’ Club members. When the football club stopped organising coaches for fans in November 1996, the Supporters’ Club took on that role.